Artist Sarah Boardman Defends Trump Portrait Amid Controversy

Apr. 7, 2025, 8:21 am ET

Instant Insight

30-Second Take

  • Colorado artist Sarah A. Boardman defends her portrait of Donald Trump against accusations of distortion.
  • Trump’s criticism led to the portrait’s removal from the Colorado State Capitol and harmed Boardman’s business.
  • Boardman has painted portraits of other U.S. presidents, including George W. Bush and Barack Obama, without similar controversy.

+ Dive Deeper

Quick Brief

2-Minute Digest

Essential Context

A portrait of Donald Trump, painted by Colorado Springs artist Sarah A. Boardman, has been at the center of controversy after Trump labeled it “purposefully distorted” and “truly the worst” in a March 23 post on Truth Social. The portrait, which was commissioned by Colorado Republicans in 2019, had been displayed in the Colorado State Capitol for six years.

Core Players

  • Sarah A. Boardman – Colorado Springs artist who painted the Trump portrait
  • Donald Trump – President Trump and subject of the portrait
  • Colorado Republicans – Commissioned the portrait in 2019
  • Paul Lundeen – Colorado Senate Minority Leader, suggested replacing the portrait

Key Numbers

  • $10,000 – Amount raised by Colorado Republicans to pay for the portrait
  • 2019 – Year the portrait was commissioned and displayed
  • 6 years – Duration the portrait was displayed in the Colorado State Capitol
  • 41 years – Length of Boardman’s career, now impacted by Trump’s comments

+ Full Analysis

Full Depth

Complete Coverage

The Catalyst

Trump’s criticism on Truth Social was the catalyst for the controversy. He stated, “I much prefer having no portrait in the Colorado Capitol to that one,” and added that Boardman “must have lost her talent as she got older.”

This led to legislative leaders announcing the removal of the portrait the next day, which was then relegated to museum storage.

Inside Forces

Boardman denied any intentional distortion, stating she completed the portrait “accurately, without ‘purposeful distortion,’ political bias, or any attempt to caricature the subject.”

She emphasized that the portrait was approved by a Colorado Capitol advisory committee and that she received overwhelmingly positive feedback over the six years it was displayed.

Power Dynamics

Trump’s influence led to the swift removal of the portrait, highlighting his significant impact on public discourse and the decisions of legislative leaders.

Boardman’s career, spanning over 41 years, is now at risk due to Trump’s comments, which she claims are “directly and negatively impacting” her business.

Outside Impact

The controversy has broader implications for artists and public figures. It raises questions about the role of criticism and personal opinions in shaping public perception and professional outcomes.

Colorado Senate Minority Leader Paul Lundeen suggested replacing the portrait with one that depicts Trump’s contemporary likeness, indicating ongoing political involvement in artistic representations.

Future Forces

The process of commissioning a replacement portrait has not yet begun, but it is expected to be a contentious issue given the current political climate.

Boardman’s situation may also prompt discussions about the protection of artists from public figures’ criticisms and the importance of maintaining artistic integrity.

Data Points

  • March 23, 2025 – Date of Trump’s post criticizing the portrait
  • March 24, 2025 – Date the portrait was removed from the Colorado State Capitol
  • 2010 – Year Boardman was selected to create official portraits through a nationwide “Call for Artists”
  • Barack Obama and George W. Bush – Other U.S. presidents whose portraits were painted by Boardman

The controversy surrounding the Trump portrait highlights the complex interplay between art, politics, and public opinion. As the situation unfolds, it will be important to watch how it impacts not only Boardman’s career but also the broader landscape of artistic representation in public spaces.