Trump Threatens Rosie O’Donnell Citizenship, Experts Cite Unconstitutionality

Jul. 12, 2025, 7:55 pm ET

Instant Insight

30-Second Take

  • President Trump threatens to revoke Rosie O’Donnell’s citizenship, citing her opposition to his administration
  • O’Donnell moved to Ireland in January and is pursuing citizenship through family lineage
  • Legal experts confirm citizenship revocation is unconstitutional under the 14th Amendment

+ Dive Deeper

Quick Brief

2-Minute Digest

Essential Context

President Trump announced Saturday he’s considering revoking comedian Rosie O’Donnell’s U.S. citizenship, claiming she’s “not in the best interests” of the country. O’Donnell, who relocated to Ireland in January, has been a vocal critic of Trump’s policies and personal conduct. Legal experts immediately dismissed the threat as unconstitutional, citing the 14th Amendment’s citizenship protections.

Core Players

  • President Trump – President of the United States
  • Rosie O’Donnell – Comedian and political commentator
  • 14th Amendment – Constitutional safeguard against citizenship revocation
  • Ireland – O’Donnell’s current residence and potential citizenship destination

Key Numbers

  • 2025 – Year Trump made citizenship threat
  • January 2025 – Month O’Donnell moved to Ireland
  • 14th Amendment – Constitutional article protecting citizenship
  • 63 – O’Donnell’s age

+ Full Analysis

Full Depth

Complete Coverage

The Catalyst

“Because of the fact that Rosie O’Donnell is not in the best interests of our Great Country, I am giving serious consideration to taking away her Citizenship,” President Trump wrote in a Saturday social media post. He suggested Ireland should “keep her” if they want her.

O’Donnell responded by calling Trump a “criminal con man” and reaffirming her opposition to his policies.

Inside Forces

The threat follows O’Donnell’s recent criticism of Trump’s tax cuts and spending policies. She has been a vocal opponent since his first presidential campaign, frequently clashing on social media.

President Trump’s statement appears to escalate their long-standing feud, which predates his political career.

Power Dynamics

President Trump’s threat highlights his willingness to use executive power against political opponents, despite constitutional limitations. Legal experts note citizenship revocation requires voluntary renunciation or treason convictions – neither applicable here.

O’Donnell’s move to Ireland and pursuit of dual citizenship may have prompted Trump’s reaction, though she remains a U.S. citizen.

Outside Impact

Constitutional law scholars immediately condemned the threat as unenforceable. “The 14th Amendment explicitly protects citizenship from government revocation,” said one expert. “This is political theater, not legal action.”

Immigration advocates warn such rhetoric could normalize attacks on citizenship rights, particularly for naturalized citizens.

Future Forces

Key developments to watch:

  • Potential legal challenges if President Trump pursues citizenship revocation
  • O’Donnell’s progress toward Irish citizenship
  • Congressional response to Trump’s constitutional overreach claims
  • Public opinion shifts regarding presidential power limits

Data Points

  • 1868 – Year 14th Amendment ratified
  • January 2025 – O’Donnell’s relocation to Ireland
  • 63 – O’Donnell’s age
  • 79 – Trump’s age
  • 2025 – Year of citizenship threat

The situation underscores ongoing tensions between presidential authority and constitutional safeguards. While Trump’s threat carries no legal weight, it highlights broader debates about political retribution and citizenship protections.