Supreme Court to Weigh U.S. Terror Lawsuits Against Palestinian Authorities

Dec. 6, 2024, 5:50 pm ET

Instant Insight

30-Second Take

  • Supreme Court to determine if Palestinian authorities face U.S. lawsuits for terrorist attacks
  • Cases involve $655 million in damages for American victims and families
  • Decision will impact 2019 anti-terrorism law’s constitutionality

+ Dive Deeper

Quick Brief

2-Minute Digest

Essential Context

The Supreme Court will review whether Palestinian authorities can face U.S. court jurisdiction for terrorism attacks against Americans. The case challenges the 2019 Promoting Security and Justice for Victims of Terrorism Act, which aimed to help victims seek justice through American courts.

Core Players

  • U.S. Supreme Court – Final arbiter of constitutional questions
  • Palestinian Authority (PA) and PLO – Defendants facing litigation
  • American victims and families – Seeking legal redress
  • Biden Administration – Supporting victims’ appeal

Key Numbers

  • $655 million – Original jury verdict (later overturned)
  • 33 – Americans killed in early 2000s attacks
  • 2019 – Year PSJVTA enacted
  • June 2025 – Expected ruling deadline

Full Depth

Complete Coverage

The Catalyst

The case originated from terrorist attacks in 2002-2004 and a 2018 stabbing that killed or wounded American citizens.

Multiple court reversals of victim compensation triggered Congressional action through the 2019 PSJVTA.

Inside Forces

The 2nd Circuit Court consistently ruled against U.S. court jurisdiction over Palestinian authorities.

Congress specifically designed the PSJVTA to overcome these jurisdictional hurdles.

Power Dynamics

The Supreme Court’s decision will balance Congressional authority against constitutional due process requirements.

International diplomatic implications weigh heavily on the case’s outcome.

Outside Impact

The ruling will set precedent for future international terrorism cases in U.S. courts.

Outcome could affect U.S.-Palestinian relations and international legal cooperation.

Future Forces

Key considerations ahead:

  • Spring 2025 oral arguments
  • Potential international law implications
  • Future terrorism case jurisdiction
  • Diplomatic relationship impacts

Data Points

  • 2002-2004: Period of initial attacks
  • 2018: West Bank stabbing incident
  • 2016: Initial verdict overturned
  • 2019: PSJVTA enacted
  • 2024: Supreme Court accepts case