Wisconsin Man Returns to U.S. After Faking Death in Kayak Scheme

Dec. 11, 2024, 1:30 pm ET

Instant Insight

30-Second Take

  • Wisconsin man stages elaborate kayaking disappearance, flees to Europe
  • Four-month investigation reveals carefully planned escape scheme
  • Suspect returns to U.S. custody following international manhunt

+ Dive Deeper

Quick Brief

Essential Context

Ryan Borgwardt orchestrated an elaborate disappearance on Wisconsin’s Green Lake, triggering a massive search operation that lasted nearly two months. His plan unraveled when investigators discovered pre-planned financial transactions and travel arrangements.

Core Players

  • Ryan Borgwardt (45) – Wisconsin resident who staged disappearance
  • Sheriff Mark Podoll – Green Lake County Sheriff leading investigation
  • Green Lake County Sheriff’s Office – Primary investigating agency

Key Numbers

  • $375,000 – Value of recently acquired life insurance policy
  • 54 days – Duration of lake search operation
  • 200 feet – Maximum depth of Green Lake
  • 120 days – Time between disappearance and arrest

Full Depth

The Catalyst

On August 12, 2024, Borgwardt’s overturned kayak was discovered on Green Lake, sparking an extensive search operation. Investigators later determined he had methodically planned his escape, including securing travel documents and moving money overseas.

Inside Forces

Investigators uncovered a trail of premeditated actions: transferred funds to foreign accounts, created new email addresses, and purchased airline cards. Borgwardt had also taken out a substantial life insurance policy just seven months before his disappearance.

Power Dynamics

The investigation required coordination between local law enforcement, international authorities, and financial institutions. Sheriff Podoll’s team pieced together digital evidence revealing Borgwardt’s careful planning and subsequent movements.

Outside Impact

The case has highlighted vulnerabilities in missing persons investigations and insurance fraud prevention. Local emergency resources were tied up for nearly two months in the search operation.

Future Forces

Prosecutors are preparing multiple charges, including potential insurance fraud and filing false reports. The case may lead to stricter protocols for life insurance policies and missing persons investigations.

Data Points

  • January 2024: Life insurance policy purchased
  • August 12, 2024: Reported missing
  • August 13, 2024: Entered Canada
  • October 5, 2024: Search operation concluded
  • December 10, 2024: Taken into custody

The investigation continues as authorities prepare for a December 11 news conference to detail charges and the circumstances of Borgwardt’s return to U.S. custody.